Write a classic chocolate chip cookie recipe. It must have exactly these sections in this order: Ingredients, Equipment, Steps, Tips. Use numbered lists for Steps and bulleted lists for everything else.

Judge: Exactly the four required sections in order (Ingredients, Equipment, Steps, Tips), with numbered Steps and bulleted Ingredients/Equipment/Tips, satisfying all hard constraints. The recipe has correct proportions and sensible tips and would produce good cookies. Clean and clear.

Judge: All four sections appear in the exact required order with numbered Steps and bulleted lists everywhere else. The recipe itself is a sound Toll House-style formula with correct proportions, sensible technique, and genuinely useful tips (chilling dough, spoon-and-level flour, cooling sheets between batches). Clear, well-organized, and fully compliant.

Judge: Exactly four sections in the required order, Steps as a numbered list, and bullets for Ingredients, Equipment, and Tips, with no extra sections. The recipe itself is the classic, correctly proportioned chocolate chip cookie formula with sensible bake parameters and genuinely useful tips. Essentially flawless against every requirement.

Judge: Exactly four sections in the required order with numbered Steps and bulleted Ingredients, Equipment, and Tips—fully compliant. The recipe uses the classic Toll House proportions, the steps are complete and correctly ordered, and the tips (chilling, residual carryover baking, flaky salt) are genuinely useful. Clean, easy-to-follow formatting.

Judge: Perfect format compliance: four sections in exact order, numbered Steps, bulleted everything else. The recipe itself is excellent -- correct proportions matching the classic Toll House recipe, sensible equipment list, and useful tips about butter temperature and dough chilling.

Judge: Perfect format compliance: 4 sections in exact order (Ingredients, Equipment, Steps, Tips), Steps use numbered list, all others use bulleted lists. The recipe itself is excellent -- classic Toll House proportions, clear steps, useful tips about chilling dough and flour measurement. Would produce great cookies.

Judge: Perfect format compliance: 4 sections in exact order (Ingredients, Equipment, Steps, Tips), Steps uses numbered list, everything else uses bulleted lists. The recipe itself is solid -- proper proportions (1c butter, 1c each sugar, 3c flour), correct technique (cream butter and sugar, add dry gradually), good tips (don't overbake, chill for thickness, cookie scoop). Would make excellent cookies. Clarity is strong throughout.

Judge: Perfect format compliance: exactly 4 sections in correct order (Ingredients, Equipment, Steps, Tips), numbered list for Steps, bulleted lists for everything else. The recipe itself is a classic Toll House-style cookie recipe with correct proportions. Tips are practical and useful (room temperature ingredients, don't overmix, chill dough). Would genuinely make good cookies.

Judge: Has exactly the required 4 sections in correct order (Ingredients, Equipment, Steps, Tips). Steps uses numbered lists, other sections use bulleted lists as specified. Content is a solid, standard chocolate chip cookie recipe. Well-formatted and easy to follow.

Judge: Fully compliant: exactly four sections in the required order with numbered Steps and bulleted lists elsewhere, no preamble or trailing text. The recipe is complete and correct (a standard Toll House variant with 1/2 tsp salt) and the tips are practical. Solid, clean execution without quite the depth of the best tips sections.

Judge: Perfect format compliance: exactly 4 sections in correct order (Ingredients, Equipment, Steps, Tips), numbered steps, bulleted everything else. The recipe itself is a classic Toll House-style recipe with correct proportions. Tips are genuinely useful (chilling dough, don't overbake). Would produce excellent cookies.

Judge: Perfect format compliance: 4 sections in exact order (Ingredients, Equipment, Steps, Tips), numbered Steps, bulleted everything else. Recipe is a recognizable, correct chocolate chip cookie recipe with standard proportions. Good tips section with practical advice. Clean execution of a structured format task.

Judge: Has all 4 sections in the correct order (Ingredients, Equipment, Steps, Tips). Steps use numbered lists, everything else uses bulleted lists. The recipe itself is a solid, standard chocolate chip cookie recipe with correct proportions and practical tips. Format compliance is excellent. Only minor deductions for the recipe being standard rather than distinctive.

Judge: Has all 4 sections in correct order. Steps correctly use numbered list. However, Ingredients uses a numbered list instead of bullets (hard constraint violation). Equipment and Tips correctly use bullets. The recipe itself is solid and would produce good cookies. The format violation on Ingredients is the primary issue.