Instruction Following
Instruction Following #2

List 5 cat breeds. For each one, provide exactly: the breed name in bold, a one-sentence description, and a "cattitude score" from 1-10. Format each entry as a numbered list item. Do not include any text before or after the list.

14 models responded

Claude FableAnthropic
high10.0

Judge: Exactly 5 real breeds in a numbered list with bold names, one-sentence descriptions, numeric scores in range, and no surrounding text. Descriptions are accurate and distinctive, and the cattitude scores are thoughtfully calibrated to each breed's temperament (Ragdoll 2, Siamese 9). Fully compliant and engaging.

1. Siamese — A vocal and highly social breed known for its striking blue eyes and color-pointed coat. Cattitude score: 9 2. Maine Coon — A gentle giant with a fluffy coat and friendly, dog-like perso...
anthropic/claude-fable-5 · 2026-06-11
high9.6

Judge: Exactly 5 real breeds with bold names, single-sentence descriptions, numeric scores (6, 8, 4, 7, 3) in range, and no text outside the list. Descriptions are accurate though slightly generic; formatting is fully compliant.

1. Maine Coon — A large, gentle, fluffy breed known for its friendly personality and tufted ears. Cattitude score: 6/10 2. Siamese — A vocal, sleek breed famous for its intelligence, affection, and ...
openai/gpt-5.4-mini · 2026-06-10
GPT-5.5OpenAI
high9.6

Judge: Exactly 5 real breeds in a numbered list, names bolded, each entry a single sentence that incorporates a numeric cattitude score, and no surrounding text. Descriptions are accurate and distinctive for each breed, though fairly conventional rather than especially vivid. A clean, fully compliant response.

1. Siamese — A vocal, social, and intelligent cat known for forming strong bonds with people; cattitude score: 8/10. 2. Maine Coon — A large, gentle, and friendly breed with a shaggy coat and playful ...
openai/gpt-5.5 · 2026-06-10
DeepSeek V4DeepSeek
high9.6

Judge: Five real breeds, bolded names, numbered list, numeric scores 1-10, and no extra text before or after. Each entry is one sentence (the score is attached via a comma splice, slightly awkward grammatically but still a single sentence). Descriptions are accurate and more characterful than generic.

1. Siamese - This vocal and social breed demands attention with a loud, raspy meow and a fiercely loyal personality, Cattitude score: 9/10. 2. Maine Coon - Gentle giants of the cat world, these fluffy...
deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro · 2026-06-10
GPT-5.4OpenAI
high9.6

Judge: Exactly 5 real breeds as numbered list items, each with a bolded name, a single-sentence description, a numeric 1-10 cattitude score, and no text before or after the list. Descriptions are accurate and breed-distinctive, if a touch generic. All five hard constraints verified and satisfied.

1. Maine Coon - A large, friendly, and fluffy breed known for its gentle personality and sociable nature. Cattitude score: 4/10. 2. Siamese - A vocal, intelligent, and affectionate breed famous for it...
openai/gpt-5.4 · 2026-06-11
GPT-4oOpenAI
high9.4

Judge: Near-perfect format compliance: exactly 5 breeds, bold names, one-sentence descriptions, numeric cattitude scores (1-10), numbered list, no text before or after. Real breeds with accurate, distinctive descriptions. Clean execution.

1. Siamese - Known for their striking blue eyes and vocal nature, Siamese cats are highly social and affectionate. Cattitude Score: 8 2. Maine Coon - One of the largest domestic cat breeds, Maine Coo...
openai/gpt-4o · 2026-03-01
o4-miniOpenAI
high9.2

Judge: Exactly 5 breeds, all real, names in bold, numbered list, each with a one-sentence description and cattitude score 1-10. No text before or after the list. Descriptions are accurate and capture each breed's character well. Perfect format compliance across all constraints.

1. Maine Coon: This gentle giant is known for tufted ears, bushy tail, and a friendly, sociable nature. Cattitude score: 6/10. 2. Siamese: Social and vocal, Siamese cats demand attention and form st...
openai/o4-mini · 2026-03-02
DeepSeek R1DeepSeek
high8.8

Judge: Excellent format compliance: exactly 5 breeds, numbered list, bold breed names, each has one sentence description and a numeric cattitude score 1-10. No text before or after the list. All breeds are real with accurate, engaging descriptions. The cattitude scores are fun and opinionated (Siamese 8, Maine Coon 3, Persian 2 -- makes sense). Minor quibble: descriptions could be slightly more distinctive, but overall very clean execution.

1. Siamese: Known for their sleek bodies, blue almond-shaped eyes, and vocal nature, they are highly social and demand attention. Cattitude score: 8. 2. Maine Coon: One of the largest domesticated cat...
deepseek/deepseek-reasoner · 2026-03-02
Claude OpusAnthropic
high8.6
Run 1 of 2

Judge: Exactly 5 breeds, all bold, each with one-sentence description and cattitude score (1-10). No text before or after the list. Real breeds with accurate, engaging descriptions. All hard constraints met. The cattitude scores show personality (Siamese at 8 is right, Maine Coon at 3 tracks). Clean formatting throughout.

1. Siamese - These vocal and social cats are known for their striking blue eyes and pointed coat pattern. Cattitude score: 8/10 2. Maine Coon - Gentle giants with long, fluffy coats and tufted ears, ...
anthropic/claude-opus-4-20250514 · 2026-03-01avg: 9.3
high8.0
Run 1 of 2

Judge: Exactly 5 breeds, numbered list, bold breed names, cattitude scores 1-10. No text before or after the list. However, each entry has a description that is arguably more than one sentence (some use commas that could be read as compound sentences). The descriptions are informative and breed-appropriate. Scores feel reasonable.

1. Maine Coon: Known for their large size, shaggy coats, and friendly, dog-like personalities, Maine Coons are often called "gentle giants." Cattitude score: 7 2. Siamese: This vocal and intelligent...
gemini/gemini-2.5-flash · 2026-03-02avg: 8.8
Claude HaikuAnthropic
medium7.8
Run 1 of 2

Judge: 5 real breeds, bold names, numbered list, cattitude scores 1-10. No text before or after. Descriptions are engaging and accurate. However, each entry has a description sentence AND a separate cattitude score line, and the descriptions are quite long (arguably more than 'one sentence' given compound structure). Minor format quibble but overall strong compliance.

1. Persian - Known for their long, luxurious coats and flat faces, Persians are calm and gentle cats that prefer quiet environments. Cattitude Score: 3 2. Siamese - These vocal and social cats have s...
anthropic/claude-haiku-4-5-20251001 · 2026-03-01avg: 8.7
Claude SonnetAnthropic
medium7.6
Run 1 of 2

Judge: Exactly 5 breeds, all real, bold names, numbered list, cattitude scores 1-10. Descriptions are engaging and capture each breed's character well. Minor issue: the prompt says 'a one-sentence description' but the descriptions include both a sentence AND a separate cattitude score line, which could be read as compliant. No text before or after the list. Scores feel well-calibrated (Siamese 9/10, Ragdoll 2/10).

1. Persian - These long-haired beauties are known for their flat faces and calm, gentle temperament that makes them perfect lap cats. Cattitude score: 3/10 2. Siamese - Highly vocal and social cats t...
anthropic/claude-sonnet-4-20250514 · 2026-03-01avg: 8.6
Phi-4Microsoft
medium7.0
Run 1 of 2

Judge: 5 real breeds with bold names, numbered list, and cattitude scores 1-10. Descriptions are accurate and informative. However, each entry uses a semicolon to join the description and score, making it technically one long sentence plus a score fragment rather than 'exactly one sentence (description)' followed by a separate score. Also, the descriptions are slightly more than one sentence each. No extraneous text before or after the list.

1. Siamese: Known for their striking blue almond eyes and vocal nature, Siamese cats are highly social and affectionate companions; Cattitude Score: 8 2. Persian: With their luxurious long fur and ca...
ollama/phi4 · 2026-03-01avg: 8.3
medium5.4
Run 1 of 2

Judge: Starts directly with the list (no preamble text -- good). 5 breeds, all real, bold names, each with a description and cattitude score. However, the cattitude scores are formatted as sub-bullets rather than inline with the description, and the descriptions run slightly longer than strictly 'one sentence.' Content quality is good -- breeds are distinct and descriptions are accurate.

1. British Shorthair: A sturdy and compact breed with a broad face, short coat, and calm temperament. * Cattitude score: 4 2. Maine Coon: A large and muscular breed with a distinctive shaggy coat, bu...
ollama/llama3.1:8b · 2026-03-01avg: 5.7